But a fine katana can be a truly awesome sword. These are significant matters that get at the heart of why such a question as who would "win" or who is the "better" fighter or even whose equipment was better really is unanswerable.
Knights were also expected to protect the church and women who they did not think very high of. There are many universal commonalities and shared fundamentals between both European and Japanese feudal warriors, but there were also significant technical and stylistic differences in their respective approaches.
Le pont mirabeau analysis essay Le pont mirabeau analysis essay professional essays writers la redistribution des revenus dissertation my favourite animal horse essay research paper about multiple sclerosis. The reach factor also cannot be overlooked.
Though there were single-edge versions, it generally has two edges that can be used, as well as a versatile crossguard and pommel permitting a variety of specialized techniques. The average European two-hand sword is longer in handle and blade than the average katana by several inches to as much as a foot or more and is not at all slow.
A shield can be used offensively in a number of ways and at very close range. It can also more easily employ its versatile hilt in binding, Knights vs samurai essay, and striking. In matters like this we certainly cannot not invoke mystical principles or endless "what ifs" and still engage in intelligent conjecture.
A sword can cut quite Knights vs samurai essay from almost all angles around or underneath a shield. In one sense we are talking about very different approaches to armed personal defense in this comparison.
The Scenario First of all, we must ask where is it these two lone warriors would meet?
All rights are reserved. Each of the two historical warriors in question did fight with equivalent technologies, under fairly similar climates and terrain, and for similar reasons.
They're both fruit, both delicious, but you can do different, though very similar, things with each. Without the necessary weapons designed intentionally to face and defeat plate armor, any fighter armed with a sword alone would have difficulty katana or not.
They were very effective.
By the 18th century their blades, no longer used earnestly against armor, tended to be made longer, lighter, and thinner for classroom practicing. I have long been an admirer of its form and function.
Educated Guesses As our hypothetical fight ensued, any number of things might happen. Longsword and Katana Considered End Note: As can be seen, there are just far too many variables and unknowns to make a judgment either way for such a theoretical question as who could defeat whom between knights and samurai.
Knightly arms and armor were the result of a dynamic interaction of Latin, Celtic, and Germanic cultures as well as Turkish and Arabic influences.
Of course, against good armor such actions can be negligible and fighting against shields was relatively unknown in Japan.
The half-swording techniques of the longsword would also not be nearly as viable here, though its hilt design might prove very useful.
The wider style can make a somewhat greater variety of strikes and delivers more effective cuts overall. Or will he be a Teutonic knight of circa in a head-to-toe suit of articulated Gothic plate-armor and bastard sword?
Differences between them are result of the particularities of their functions and the ways they accomplish their goals. While it is known that the average samurai had a large inventory of unarmed fighting techniques at his disposal, these too Knights vs samurai essay be unlikely to play a part against a shield wielding warrior.
The first has been done many times; I know of no recorded case of the second, but the perfection of the edge and the ease of cutting with it makes it not improbable. We classify each as longswords because both were blade weapons designed for the same purpose, killing.
There are many other factors that still could be raised when speculating on a hypothetical combat between a knight and a samurai. Still, it's an interesting encounter to consider.
It could be argued that the samurai by nature could have a tactical advantage in attitude and fortitude as a result of the psychological elements of his training and fighting methods. The katana's exceptionally hard edge was prone to chipping and needed frequent re-polishing and its blade could break or bend the same as any other sword might But the later is more agile and easier to guard and parry with.
Yet, as a long, straight blade tapering to a keen point, the longsword is a better thruster. Chronicle, Kobe Japan, Although a skilled warrior could certainly improvise some, those unfamiliar with the formidable effectiveness and versatility of a sword and shield combination will have a hard time.
Nor can I ignore the formidable utility and versatility of an excellent European longsword or great sword when combined with superior European armor —and the difficulty it offers when posed against the single sword.
So, if instead of a shield and sword we match a knight with a longsword or greatsword against the katana armed samurai this could make a significant difference.Comparison between Knights and Samurai Rank Knights-Expected to be an noble Code of Bushido and Chivalry Samurai have rules that they must follow called "Bushido".
Knights are the same, but their rule is different. Knight follow the Chivalry. Practice Tactics There were many tactics in battle. Cheating, ambushing and straight-on attacking. Comparison between Knights and Samurai Rank Knights-Expected to be an noble Code of Bushido and Chivalry Samurai have rules that they must follow called "Bushido".
Knights are the same, but their rule is different. Knight follow the Chivalry. Practice Tactics There were many tactics in battle. Cheating, ambushing and straight-on attacking. The knights of circa and the samurai of circa were roughly evenly matched in equipment.
But the same comparative warriors during the 's for instance, were quite dissimilar. An essay or paper on Comparison Between a Samurai & Knight.
Many people often see little similarity between the country of Japan and Europe. However, there are actually several similarities between these two countries. In fact, Reischauer and Jansen note that Feudal Japan had departed so far from East Asian norms that it was more similar to medieval Europ.
Samurai and Knights Essay For six centuries the medieval knight dominated the battlefield and influenced the Western world greatly. The armored, mounted warrior, born in Middle Ages, revolutionized warfare and became the foundation of the new political structure known as feudalism.
Differences and Similarities Between Knights and Samurai Knights and Samurai Knights and Samurai had many similarities, but also a few differences.Download